Guest Commentary by John Sherman: The Collective Failure of Educational Institutions in Boston to Assess the Risk of Transmission to the Community is a Scandal

In this guest commentary, attorney John Sherman refutes the argument that holding in-person classes is justified because the current rate of COVID infection is low and if it rises, we can just revert to online classes. John Sherman is an attorney with expertise in business and human rights. He is Senior Program Fellow at the Corporate Responsibility Initiative at the Harvard Kennedy School, an Executive Fellow at the Hoffman Center for Business Ethics at Bentley University, and Senior Advisor and General Counsel of Shift.

The Collective Failure of Educational Institutions in Boston to Assess the Risk of Transmission to the Community is a Scandal

In the WGBH audio, the dean of the school of public health said that he supported the school’s decision to reopen because Massachusetts numbers are low, but if that changes, BU would have to change as well.  

I found that comment to be very disturbing, since it does not reflect the likelihood that the transmission of the virus from BU as well as the many other colleges in the area, will increase the numbers for all surrounding communities, such as North Brookline where I live.  

I'm not a public health professional, but this reflects a myopic view of the public health risk. 

Risk of transmission doesn’t come just from BU. It comes from the tens of thousands of students in the 14 major institutions in the Boston area. 

None of their campuses are self contained bubbles. They all reside in or near highly dense urban neighborhoods that are home to vulnerable persons, such as people of color, low income, and disabled. Hard numbers are difficult to come by (mainly because the universities are not transparent), but I believe that well over half of the student population from colleges and universities in the Boston area live off campus.  

These communities include Allston, Brighton, Brookline, Kenmore, Fenway, Roxbury, Dorchester, Mattapan, Cambridge, Medford, and Somerville.

Whatever colleges and universities do on campus to control the virus, they are unable to control what happens in off-campus apartment buildings. For example, reports from my neighbors in North Brookline are that off-campus parties have been in full swing.

It only takes one or two infected persons at a party to turn it into a spreading event. That has upended the University of Illinois’ highly sophisticated virus model, according to the New York Times yesterday.

To the best of my knowledge, none of these colleges and universities In Boston are collaborating in their testing/tracing/quarantining.  Each institution is on its own. Some, like BU and Harvard, have robust processes. Others, with smaller resources, who knows?

I am not aware that any such institution has assessed the risk of transmission to communities. Moreover, I am unaware that any institution is taking steps to mitigate the impact of the risk of community transmission, such as offering testing, etc., to neighbors.

A collective failure by these institutions to look at the risk of transmission to the community at large, and to take steps to mitigate that risk, is a scandal.  It signifies  atrophy of the sense of a common good. After all, we all breathe the same air.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Copy of My Open Letter to the BU School of Public Health Community

This is perhaps the most difficult note I have written in my career. It comes out of a deep love for the School of Public Health, a love that has been engendered by 25 years (as of six days ago) of being a part of an institution with a singular mission to use scientific principles and methods to think about public health problems, to teach our students principles to go out and improve the world, and to demonstrate our commitment to public health and social justice by do ing – that is, implementing these principles in our own actions and policies as a school. It is based on a careful analysis of these principles that I have reached the conclusion that led me to convey this message: It is essential that we rescind the decision to hold in-person/hybrid classes and transition immediately to online-only classes, not merely to protect the health of the community and the public, but to restore our ability to carry out our mission as a school of public health. Our decision to hol...
Read more

Despite the Claims of Safety, Spending Three Hours in an Indoor Classroom Entails Significant COVID Risk

Initial theories about the spread of COVID-19 attributed the majority of cases to exposure to large droplets which are exhaled by people who are infected and then tend to drop rather quickly to the ground. This is why very close exposure was thought to be critical for infection to occur and why the six foot rule was widely accepted as conveying protection. However, more recently, there has emerged a compelling body of research demonstrating that COVID-19 can also spread through aerosols, much smaller particles that tend to rise rather than fall and can spread much longer distances as well as enter ventilation systems and continue to provide potential exposure for much longer periods of time. For example, a study by Shen et al. concluded : "To inform the knowledge gap and investigate potential transmission routes of COVID-19, we present the result from an outbreak investigation of COVID-19 among lay Buddhists worshiping in a temple. The attack rate on an enclosed bus containing ...
Read more

Open Letter to the Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education

[NOTE: THIS OPEN LETTER IS POSTED AT MY WEBSITE AND IS BEING MADE AVAILABLE WIDELY TO THE MEDIA – IT MAY BE REPRODUCED FREELY WITH ATTRIBUTION] Dear Commissioner Riley and Members of the Board of Elementary and Secondary Education: I am a professor in the public health program at the Tufts University School of Medicine and an epidemiologist who was trained in infectious disease outbreak response at CDC. I am writing to urge you to immediately allow schools to hold virtual classes for the next 2-3 weeks, or at least until the astronomical rate of increase in COVID-19 hospitalizations in Massachusetts subsides. Opening schools in-person at this time is going to be disastrous, both for our local communities and for the devastating situation that our hospitals are already facing. I hope you will consider allowing schools to implement a 2-3 week delay before forcing students to return to school in-person. The issue is not the safety of our students, or even of our staff. It is s...
Read more